selling GPL sources

Guilherme C. Hazan guich at
Mon Sep 19 23:52:13 UTC 2005


>>> I'm aware of a program that uses the GPL license and the author made
>>> the binaries free but not the sources. He asks a fee for the sources
>>> (about 100usd).
>>> Is this legal or is he infringing the GPL license?
>> The GPL permits "a charge no more than your cost of physically
>> performing source distribution."  If his cost is 100USD or greater,
>> than he is not infringing.  If his cost is less than 100USD, then he
>> is infringing.
> The original poster said this person was the "author" of the program. If
> he in fact owns all copyright, then he can do whatever weird distribution
> scheme he wants, yes? Other people, if they happen to somehow receive a
> copy licensed under the GPL, would then need to follow the GPL if they
> wanted to distribute it (or derivative works) further.

This makes sense. But suppose the author just want to use GPL, not a 
weird license. Or lets suppose that someone else but the author gets the 
GPLd software and asks for a fee of the sources. Without any other 
assumptions (such as this doesnt make sense bc others can give the 
source for free), will this be illegal?



More information about the License-discuss mailing list