[License-review] PSCL Python Statistics Calculator Review

[Carlo Piana]

All, 

I suspect trolling here. 

I would suggest not to interact further unless a named bona fide submitter shows up. 

Cheers 

Carlo 

> Da: "Kevin P. Fleming" <lists.osi-license-review at kevin.km6g.us>
> A: "License submissions for OSI review" <license-review at lists.opensource.org>
> Inviato: Lunedì, 4 novembre 2024 16:09:27
> Oggetto: Re: [License-review] PSCL Python Statistics Calculator Review

> On Thu, Oct 31, 2024, at 06:07, Recovery Account via License-review wrote:

>> Dear OSI License Review Committee,

>> I am submitting the Python Statistics Calculator License (PSCL) for your review
>> and approval. The PSCL is designed to balance open-source collaboration with
>> quality control by restricting modifications to experienced and intermediate
>> developers, and it features a unique Criterion for Speedy Protection (CFSP)
>> mechanism to safeguard against unconstructive modifications.

> Please follow the submission process: [
> https://opensource.org/licenses/review-process |
> https://opensource.org/licenses/review-process ] . There are many pieces of
> information which the submitter must provide in addition to the text of the
> license.

>> Attached is a detailed proposal outlining the purpose, comparisons with existing
>> licenses, and the full text of the PSCL.

> The promised 'comparisons' are not present.

>> ### **Python Statistics Calculator License (PSCL) Documentation**

>> #### **Overview**
>> The Python Statistics Calculator License (PSCL) outlines the terms and
>> conditions for using, copying, distributing, and creating derivative works from
>> the Python Statistics Calculator software. This license aims to balance
>> flexibility with control, ensuring the integrity of the software while
>> promoting contributions from experienced and intermediate developers.

>> #### **License Terms**

>> 1. **Permission**
>> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of
>> this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to copy,
>> distribute, and create derivative works from the Software for commercial
>> purposes, subject to the following conditions:

> This is a violation of OSD 6, as it only permits these actions 'for commercial
> purposes'.

>> 2. **Attribution**
>> You must give appropriate credit to the author by providing a link to the
>> original work. This helps recognize the contributions of the original authors
>> and maintain the credibility of the software.

>> 3. **Modification by Experienced and Intermediate Developers Only**
>> Only individuals or entities with proven expertise in software development or
>> those meeting the criteria for intermediate developers are permitted to modify
>> the original work.

> This is a violation of OSD 5, discrimination against persons or groups.

>> - **Experienced Developers**: Individuals or entities with proven expertise in
>> software development, having made at least one meaningful contribution or
>> program, and proficient in creating powerful programs.
>> - **Intermediate Developers**: Individuals or entities that have created 3-7
>> programs ideal for practicing the basics of coding, can add decent styling
>> better than the average webpage, and capable of making slight improvements,
>> tweaks, or enhancements.

>> **Criterion for Speedy Protection (CFSP)**: If the project/hard work is likely
>> to have unconstructive modifications, it will be protected by this license to
>> maintain the integrity of the source code within 2-6 hours.

> This paragraph doesn't make any sense at all.

>> Any derivative works must be based on the original but not alter it directly
>> except by those qualified.

> This precludes derivatives made from other derivatives, which is a violation of
> OSD 3.

>> 4. **Distribution**
>> If you distribute the Software, you must distribute it under the same terms as
>> this license. This ensures that all copies of the Software, whether distributed
>> in their original form or as derivative works, are bound by the same
>> conditions, maintaining consistency and fairness.

>> 5. **Disclaimer**
>> The Software is provided "as is," without warranty of any kind, express or
>> implied, including but not limited to the warranties of merchantability,
>> fitness for a particular purpose, and non infringement. In no event shall the
>> authors or copyright holders be liable for any claim, damages, or other
>> liability, whether in an action of contract, tort, or otherwise, arising from,
>> out of, or in connection with the Software or the use or other dealings in the
>> Software.

>> #### **Purpose**
>> The purpose of this license is to:
>> - Ensure that the Python Statistics Calculator software remains user-friendly
>> and reliable.

> A software license is not a suitable place to ensure that software remains 'user
> friendly' or 'reliable', since those are qualitative attributes of the software
> and not subject to intellectual property protection.

>> - Allow experienced and intermediate developers to contribute meaningful
>> improvements and bug fixes, enhancing the Software's functionality and
>> performance.
>> - Promote open-source collaboration by providing a clear and fair framework for
>> using, copying, and distributing the Software.

>> #### **Definitions**

>> **Experienced Developer**: An individual or entity with proven expertise in
>> software development. The criteria for qualifying as an experienced developer
>> are:
>> - Proven expertise in software development.
>> - At least one meaningful contribution or program.
>> - Proficiency in creating powerful programs.

>> **Intermediate Developer**: An individual or entity that has created 3-7
>> programs ideal for practicing the basics of coding, can add decent styling
>> better than the average webpage, and capable of making slight improvements,
>> tweaks, or enhancements.

>> **Criterion for Speedy Protection (CFSP)**: If the project/hard work is likely
>> to have unconstructive modifications, it will be protected by this license to
>> maintain the integrity of the source code within 2-6 hours.

>> #### **Additional Information**
>> For more detailed information on how to qualify as an experienced or
>> intermediate developer, examples of proper attribution, and guidelines for
>> distributing the Software, please refer to the accompanying documentation file
>> or visit our project website.

>> Thank you for your consideration.

>> Best regards,

>> _______________________________________________
>> The opinions expressed in this email are those of the sender and not necessarily
>> those of the Open Source Initiative. Communication from the Open Source
>> Initiative will be sent from an opensource.org email address.

>> License-review mailing list
>> [ mailto:License-review at lists.opensource.org |
>> License-review at lists.opensource.org ]
>> [
>> http://lists.opensource.org/mailman/listinfo/license-review_lists.opensource.org
>> |
>> http://lists.opensource.org/mailman/listinfo/license-review_lists.opensource.org
>> ]

> _______________________________________________
> The opinions expressed in this email are those of the sender and not necessarily
> those of the Open Source Initiative. Communication from the Open Source
> Initiative will be sent from an opensource.org email address.

> License-review mailing list
> License-review at lists.opensource.org
> http://lists.opensource.org/mailman/listinfo/license-review_lists.opensource.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.opensource.org/pipermail/license-review_lists.opensource.org/attachments/20241104/154ec2e3/attachment.htm>