For Approval: SSCL

Gregor Pintar lightbit8 at gmail.com
Fri Jul 2 15:53:48 UTC 2010


2010/6/30, Schmitz, Patrice-Emmanuel <patrice-emmanuel.schmitz at be.unisys.com>:
> In my humble opinion, the main issue is not licence proliferation itself,
> which we may all regret, but which is a definitive fact (with 1,800 F/OSS
> licenses tracked by BlackDuck in January 2010 !). The main issue is the lack
> of compatibility or interoperability between copyleft licenses, because it
> makes impossible the distribution of larger solutions (combined works).
>
> Therefore, if any new license is copyleft (and it seems to be your case, as
> redistribution must reproduce the licence), it is important to add or
> clarify with something like this: "This license makes no obstacle to the
> integration of the source code as a component of a larger collective or
> combined work, when this work is distributed as a whole under the terms of
> another OSI-approved copyleft license".
>
> Good luck!
>
> Patrice-E. Schmitz
> Legal counsel - www.osor.eu

Compatibility would be nice, but if someone takes the source code into
combined work, which is licensed under GPL for example, I can't get
improvements back into my project.

2010/6/29, Bruce Perens <bruce at perens.com>:
> The big hurdle for a license like this is that it doesn't cause license
> proliferation without justification. Look at the licenses that already
> have similar effects and are not too long.

I did look at Simple Public Licence, but it permits to redistribute it
under GPLv2, so I can't get improvements back into my project.

fixed (I hope it's better now) licence:

Copyright (c) years, Company or Person's Name <E-mail address>

Permission is hereby granted to use, copy, modify and/or distribute,
this source code and binary programs derived from this source code,
provided that the following conditions are met:

- Redistributions of this source code, must retain this licence text
   and all copyright notices without alteration.

- Redistributions of binary programs which depend on this source code must
   reproduce this licence text and all copyright notices in the documentation,
   which must be distributed with binary programs.

- If the binary program depend on a modified version of this source code,
   you must to publicly release the modified version of this source code
   under this license.

THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS" AND WITHOUT ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED
WARRANTY. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY DAMAGES
ARISING FROM THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE.


Thanks for the help.



More information about the License-review mailing list