encforceability of Open Source Licences (Re: (OT) - NOT A Major Blow to Copyleft Theory)
mdpoole at troilus.org
Mon Feb 11 14:25:24 UTC 2008
Tzeng, Nigel H. writes:
>>From: zooko [mailto:zooko at zooko.com]
>>I have found Alexander Terekhov's posts very interesting (especially
>>recently, as he seems to have toned down the ad-hominem and focussed
>>his rhetoric), because of my abiding interest in Open Source.
> I guess the question is how close to reality is his analysis. Given that IANAL
> I haven't a clue but the responses to his posts have been less than
If Alexander Terekhov's analysis is close to any reality, it is a very
special reality in which he may be the only resident. I've resisted
the urge to chip in on his various odd legal claims in this thread --
he has shown before that he is willing to argue longer than I am, he
tends to repeat points that were already raised and addressed (perhaps
because he's too busy trolling to bother remembering the thread at
hand), and I'm too busy to research topics like legal arcana that have
nothing to do with my day job -- but in my previous dealings with him,
his claims have been specious: they may appear to be well-backed, but
they have deep, inherent flaws.
His comments in this thread are remarkably similar to things he has
said before in other places. One less-than-amusing tendency of his is
to make posts that are almost related to the point at hand, but which
usually leave gaps where readers are expected to supply key parts of
his argument (such as how they apply to the case at hand).
As one example of old tricks returning: When Rick Moen suggested that
Terekhov test a theory on downloaded items, I was just waiting until
Terekhov mentioned the Windows XP downloads again. I'm not sure how
"The rest 14 copies went to Debians" was meant to be parsed, but the
message he linked to does not show that he sent any copies to Debian
users or developers -- quite the opposite (which seems to be an
instance of him leaving those critical gaps for us to fill in).
More information about the License-discuss