[FWD: RE: [Ebxmlrr-tech] License issue with our customer]

Rick Moen rick at linuxmafia.com
Tue May 23 19:26:52 UTC 2006


[OSI Board of Directors snipped from distribution.]

Quoting Walter van Holst (walter.van.holst at gmail.com):

> It is hard to provide help if you're this thin on the details, especially on
> the terms of the contract under which Ladislave et al provided their
> services. If said contract states that any copyrights arising from their
> work is assigned to the client, the client's lawyers may have a, albeit
> somewhat twisted, point.

In United States jurisdictions, a conveyance of copyright title must be
in writing and signed by the owner (impliedly identifying some extant
property to be conveyed).  I very much doubt that a judge would agree
that a contract saying "Stuff you make for the next N months shall
belong to me" qualifies in that department.  (My opinion; yours for a
small fee and disclaimer of reverse-engineering rights.)

As detailed earlier, such an agreement _can_ be created and enforced 
between contractor and payer, provided that contractor specifically 
agrees to such "work for hire" treatment, but only in a specified,
limited set of fields of endeavour, that do not happen to include
software.

(Sorry, but some contract terms are just not enforceable.  Surprise.)

However, I am not going to make pronouncements about the merits of
Ladislav's particular case, and probably you shouldn't, either.  For
that, he needs to consult good professional legal counsel.





More information about the License-discuss mailing list